Whiskey Drinks to Order at a Bar, From a Guy Who Poured Them for Years

Whiskey Drinks to Order at a Bar, From a Guy Who Poured Them for Years

Good whiskey drinks to order at a bar: what to say, which ones every bar can make, sweet picks if you don't love whiskey, and what to skip at a dive bar.

“Something with whiskey.”

I heard that line maybe four times a night. It tells me nothing. Tall or short? Bourbon or Scotch? I’d pour a whiskey ginger and hope. Usually it worked. Sometimes it came back.

So here’s the cheat sheet I wish people had walked in with. It’s sorted by what the bar actually has on hand, because that decides more than the menu does.

Say three things and you’re done

The brand or the style. The drink. How you want it served.

“Jameson and ginger, tall.” “Old Fashioned, bourbon, no fruit.” “Manhattan, rye, up.” That’s it. You’ll get your drink faster than the guy reading the cocktail list out loud.

If you don’t know brands, just say the style. Bourbon is sweeter and vanilla-heavy. Rye is spicier and drier. Irish is smooth and light. Scotch can be smoky, so ask if you’re not sure. Say “well” and you get the house bottle, which at most bars is fine in a mixed drink and rough on its own.

Drinks every bar can make

These need a whiskey and something within arm’s reach of the well. No shaker.

Whiskey ginger. The most ordered whiskey highball I ever poured. Whiskey over ice, ginger ale from the gun, lime if you ask. Our whiskey ginger uses ginger beer instead, which is spicier and drier. Order it that way if the bar carries a bottle. The Jack and Ginger is the same drink with Jack Daniel’s and ginger ale. Irish whiskey here is my pick. It disappears into the ginger in a good way.

Then there’s the Jack and Coke. Fine. Honest. Nobody needs the recipe. In Canada the move is the Crown and Coke. Ask for a lime. It cuts the syrup.

A 7 and 7 is Seagram’s 7 with 7-Up. Old man drink, and I mean that kindly. Every bar with a gun can do a Seven and Seven, though not every bar still stocks Seagram’s. Any blended whiskey works.

Whiskey highball. Whiskey, soda water, a lemon twist. The driest thing on this page. Our whiskey highball is blended whiskey, lemon and carbonated water. Ask for a tall glass and lots of ice. Short glass and the soda goes flat on you.

People who find ginger ale too sweet should try the Presbyterian: bourbon, then half ginger ale and half soda. If the bartender blanks on the name, just say it like that.

Last one. A shot and a beer is a Boilermaker, the cheapest good night at any dive. Some people drop the shot in. Waste of a pint glass, if you ask me.

Stirred and short: the classics

These take a minute. Order them at a bar with at least one bartender who isn’t slammed.

The Old Fashioned is bourbon, sugar, a splash of water and Angostura bitters, stirred over ice. That’s the whole drink. Some bars muddle an orange slice and a neon cherry into it. If you don’t want fruit salad, say “no muddled fruit, orange peel.” If you build them at home, our rundown of the best bitters for an Old Fashioned is worth five minutes.

A Manhattan is whiskey, sweet vermouth and Angostura. Rye is the classic call. Up means in a stemmed glass, no ice. On the rocks is fine too. One trick. If the vermouth bottle has been open on the back bar since summer, order something else. Old vermouth tastes like wet cardboard.

The Rusty Nail is Scotch and Drambuie, a honey and heather liqueur, over ice with a lemon twist. Two bottles. Most bars have both. The Godfather is Scotch and amaretto. Same shape, nuttier. Both are sweet enough for after dinner and strong enough to sip slowly.

Shaken: the whiskey sour and friends

The whiskey sour is the drink that turns people into whiskey drinkers. At a busy bar it’s whiskey and sour mix, which is what our recipe uses. At a better bar it’s fresh lemon, sugar and sometimes egg white. Ask “fresh lemon?” before you order. If the answer is no, sour mix is still fine. Just sweeter.

Want the upgrade? A Gold Rush is bourbon, honey syrup and lemon. It’s a whiskey sour with honey in place of sugar, and I’d take it every time. The Penicillin adds ginger and a float of smoky Islay Scotch. Cocktail bar only. A dive won’t have the ginger syrup.

Sweet whiskey drinks if you don’t love whiskey

You don’t have to like the taste of whiskey to drink it. Hide it.

  • The Washington Apple is Crown Royal, sour apple schnapps and cranberry. Tastes like a Jolly Rancher. Sells out at every college bar for a reason.
  • An amaretto-leaning Godfather, mentioned above. Ask for more amaretto than Scotch.
  • A whiskey sour with extra sweet, or a Gold Rush with a little extra honey.
  • Whiskey ginger with ginger ale, not beer, plus a squeeze of orange.

For more sweet orders beyond whiskey, our list of sweet drinks to order at a bar covers vodka, rum and the rest.

Cold night: Irish coffee and the toddy

An Irish Coffee is Irish whiskey, hot coffee, brown sugar and a layer of lightly whipped cream floated on top. Don’t stir it. You drink the coffee through the cream. A bar that serves brunch can make one. A bar with no coffee machine can’t, so don’t ask at 1 a.m.

The Hot Toddy is whiskey, honey, lemon and hot water, with a tea bag in our version. Needs a kettle. Lots of pubs keep one going in winter.

At a dive bar

I worked a dive for two years. Here’s what I’d tell you from behind that bar.

Order anything from the “every bar can make” list. Whiskey and a mixer from the gun. A shot and a beer. Those are fast and they taste the same everywhere.

Skip the Manhattan. The vermouth has been open for months, no fridge. Skip anything with egg white. Skip the Old Fashioned on a Friday at 11. You’ll get a muddled mess built in eight seconds, and the person behind you will hate you for asking.

Don’t order top-shelf in a highball either. Twelve-year Scotch in Coke is money down the drain. Save the good bottle for neat or one rock.

And tip a dollar more on stirred drinks. They take longer than you think.

Making these at home

Most of these need two or three bottles. If you’ve got whiskey, ginger ale, a lemon and some bitters, you can make half this list tonight. Our guide on what to mix with whiskey goes deeper on mixers. Or plug what’s in your cabinet into CocktailBuilder and it’ll tell you what you can make right now.

My order, if you were wondering? Rye Manhattan at a cocktail bar. Jameson and ginger everywhere else.


Last modified on November 16, 2026