
What Alcohol Goes in Eggnog? Rum, Brandy, Bourbon and the Ratio
I worked a lot of December shifts, and every year somebody’s uncle leaned over the bar to ask what alcohol is supposed to go in eggnog. He got the same answer every time. Rum, brandy or bourbon, and any one of them works alone. Use 1.5 oz of spirit in a 6 oz cup of nog, which is one part booze to four parts eggnog.
The uncle always wanted to know which one was correct. All of them are. They make different drinks, and I have a favorite.
How much booze per cup
One to four is my number. One to five if the crowd is mixed or the night is long.
A 1.5 oz shot of 80 proof spirit in 6 oz of eggnog lands near 8% alcohol. That is a strong beer. Drop to 1.2 oz and you are under 7%. Push to 2 oz and you hit 10%, and the nog stops hiding it.
For a bowl, a quart of eggnog takes 8 oz of spirit. That fills eight small cups.
Spirit goes in the glass first. Nog on top. Stir, then grate nutmeg over it. Whole nutmeg and a fine grater, please. The pre-ground jar tastes like pencil shavings.
Rum
Use an aged rum. Gold or dark, something that spent a few years in a barrel. It brings molasses and a little vanilla, and eggnog loves both.
Jamaican rum is the old-school pick. It has a funky, overripe-banana edge that cuts straight through the cream. If your store carries one, buy it for this.
White rum is a waste here. I have watched people pour good silver rum into nog and then ask why they can’t taste it. The cream ate it. You get the alcohol and nothing else.
Brandy and cognac
Brandy is the drier choice. Less sweet than rum, a bit of grape and oak, and it thins the nog out so the second cup goes down easier.
A VS cognac is plenty. So is a decent American brandy at half the price. Do not pour the expensive stuff. I once watched a guest tip most of a bottle of XO into a punch bowl while the host stood there going pale. Nobody could tell.
Our database has a Brandy Eggnog built for a bowl: a quart of nog and 12 oz of brandy, nutmeg on top. That is closer to one to three. It is stiff. Put it over a block of ice or cut the brandy to 8 oz.
Bourbon
Bourbon makes the loudest cup. Caramel, char, some heat on the way down.
This is the one place a higher proof helps. A 90 or 100 proof bourbon still tastes like bourbon after the cream gets to it. An 80 proof bottle can go soft. Rye works too and comes out spicier. Tennessee whiskey is fine. Scotch is trickier, and I get to it further down.
The traditional blend
Ask what “traditionally” goes in eggnog and the honest answer is more than one bottle. Old American recipes usually mix brandy with rum. Plenty add whiskey or a fortified wine on top of that.
Two rows in our database show the pattern. Baltimore Eggnog puts 5 oz each of brandy, Jamaica rum and Madeira into a quart of nog. The Madeira sounds strange until you try it. It adds a nutty, raisin thing. Ambassador’s Punch goes 5 oz brandy, 4 oz dark rum and 3 oz dark crème de cacao, whisked into chilled eggnog in a punch bowl.
My house split is simpler. Three quarters of an ounce of bourbon and three quarters of an ounce of dark rum per cup. The bourbon gives it a spine and the rum rounds it off. If I only get to make one version all night, that is it.
The less obvious bottles
Spiced rum is the most popular answer in America, and it is sweet on sweet. Captain Morgan is 35% and heavy on vanilla. It works if you pour light. Egg Nog Captain Morgan uses 1 oz in 4 oz of nog, and I would not go over that.
Amaretto works. Almond and eggnog taste like marzipan. Good, but it is a liqueur, so it adds sugar and not much kick. I split it: half an ounce of amaretto, an ounce of bourbon.
Kahlúa is better in nog than it has any right to be. The Dirty Russian is 1.5 oz of Kahlúa and 4.5 oz of eggnog over ice, stirred until it turns one color. Coffee liqueur is low proof, so this is the gentle option. It is what I hand people who say they don’t like eggnog.
I rolled my eyes at peanut butter whiskey. Then I tried it. Skrewball is 35% and tastes like a peanut butter cookie, and in nog it tastes like the cookie got dunked. Pour 1.5 oz. There is more to do with that bottle in our Skrewball drinks post.
Fireball gets one ounce, no more. It is 33% and the cinnamon takes over fast. At an ounce you get a snickerdoodle. At two you get a candle.
Peppermint schnapps, only as a shot. Christmas Cheer is half a shot of schnapps and half a shot of nog. A full cup of minty eggnog is toothpaste.
If your shelf is all odd bottles and no plan, tell CocktailBuilder what you own and it lists the drinks you can make.
What I would not pour
Gin. Juniper and custard do not get along.
Blanco tequila. Same problem, plus pepper.
Smoky Scotch. Peat in eggnog tastes like someone put out a campfire with a milkshake. A soft blended Scotch is drinkable. An Islay malt is not.
Vodka is allowed and pointless. It makes the nog stronger and thinner and adds nothing you can taste.
Anything sour is the real mistake. Lemon juice, lime juice, sour mix, a big splash of orange juice. Acid curdles the dairy and you get lumps. I lost a whole bowl that way once, to a barback who wanted to “brighten it up.”
Cream liqueurs will not hurt you. Baileys in eggnog is just cream on cream on sugar. Half an ounce with a real spirit, if you must.
Carton or homemade
Everything above assumes a carton from the store. It is pasteurized, it is thick, and it holds booze well.
Keep it cold. A punch bowl of eggnog should not sit at room temperature for more than two hours. Set the bowl inside a bigger bowl of ice, or pour a quart at a time and keep the rest in the fridge.
Homemade is more work. If your recipe uses raw eggs, buy pasteurized eggs, or cook the egg and milk base to 160°F and chill it before the liquor goes in. A shot of rum in a cup does not make a raw egg safe. Do not count on it.
How long an opened carton keeps, spiked or not, is covered in does eggnog go bad.
If you have settled on a bottle and want named drinks, our eggnog cocktails roundup has the butterscotch one, the coconut ones and a few you can serve warm. Me, I will be at the end of the counter with the bourbon and the dark rum.
Last modified on November 22, 2026