
Skrewball Drinks: What to Mix With Peanut Butter Whiskey
Unscrew the cap and the room smells like the inside of a peanut butter jar, with vanilla and a little caramel behind it. That smell is the whole guide to mixing it. Skrewball drinks work when they pair it with whatever you would happily eat beside peanut butter: cola, raspberry, chocolate, coffee, banana, warm milk. It is a peanut butter flavored whiskey at 35% ABV (70 proof), sweeter and softer than bourbon, and it behaves more like a liqueur than a whiskey once it is in a glass.
We open a bottle in the first cold week of November. It is usually empty well before the tree comes down. Below are the five Skrewball recipes in our database with the measures we pour, and after them the cold-weather mugs.
Two rules before you pour
The whiskey itself stays in the background, and there is already a good deal of sugar in the bottle. So the first rule is to leave out the syrup a normal whiskey recipe calls for. The second is to keep citrus away from it. We made a Skrewball sour once, with fresh lemon, and nobody finished theirs.
One note for hosts: Skrewball is made with real peanuts. Tell your guests before you hand anything around, and keep the shaker you used for it away from anyone with an allergy.
The five in our database
1. Skrewball and Coke
Two ounces of Skrewball over ice in a tall glass, then four to five ounces of cold Coca-Cola and a single stir. Skrewball and Coke tastes like a cola float with peanut butter in it. We make it for people who say they don’t like whiskey. Cherry Coke is even better. Diet cola turns thin and strange against the sweetness, so we skip it.
2. The PB&J shot
Equal parts Skrewball and Chambord, three quarters of an ounce each, shaken with ice until the tin frosts and strained into a shot glass. The Skrewball PB&J Shot really does taste like the sandwich, crusts cut off. If the raspberry runs sweet for you, tip the balance to an ounce of whiskey and half an ounce of Chambord.
3. The peanut butter cup shot
This one is three bottles: Skrewball, Godiva chocolate liqueur and Baileys, half an ounce of each, shaken cold and strained. It lands somewhere between a candy bar and a milkshake. The Skrewball Peanut Butter Cup Shot is rich, and one round is plenty. If it leaves you with most of a bottle of Godiva, we have a page of Godiva chocolate liqueur drinks to use it on.
4. Skrewball Old Fashioned
Stir two ounces of Skrewball with two or three dashes of Angostura bitters over ice for about twenty seconds. Strain it over one large cube and twist a strip of orange peel over the top. Notice what is missing from the Skrewball Old Fashioned: there is no sugar, because the whiskey brings its own. The bitters dry the drink out until it tastes grown up.
If it is still too soft for you, split the base with an ounce of bourbon or rye. That is our own tweak and not part of the database recipe. It is how we drink it by the fire.
5. Skrewball Espresso Martini
Pull a shot of espresso and let it sit for a minute so it doesn’t melt all your ice. Shake it hard with an ounce and a half of Skrewball and three quarters of an ounce of Kahlua, about fifteen seconds, then strain into a chilled glass. The Skrewball Espresso Martini has no vodka in it at all. It comes out at a gentler strength than the usual version and smells like a peanut butter mocha. Strong cold brew concentrate works if you have no espresso machine, though the foam on top will be thinner.
Hot Skrewball drinks
Peanut butter and hot chocolate is the pairing we come back to every December. Stir an ounce and a half of Skrewball into eight ounces of hot chocolate and top it with whipped cream, or marshmallows if there are any left in the bag.
There is no Skrewball hot chocolate in our database yet, so here is an honest swap: the Kentucky Hot Chocolate is written with bourbon, hot chocolate and dark crème de cacao. Pour Skrewball in place of the bourbon and you have the same mug with a peanut butter cup melted into it. It gets sweet quickly that way, so we cut the crème de cacao to half an ounce or leave it out. For the other bottles that are good in a mug, see what alcohol goes in hot chocolate.
Hot coffee works too. An ounce and a half in a mug of black coffee, with a spoon of whipped cream on top, makes a decent stand-in for an Irish coffee. You can skip the brown sugar. Warm milk with Skrewball and a little cinnamon is the quietest drink on this page. We make it on weeknights.
Skrewball and eggnog
It sounds like too much. It is very nearly too much, and we like it anyway. Use one part Skrewball to four parts cold eggnog, so an ounce and a half of whiskey to six ounces of nog, and grate nutmeg over the glass.
At that ratio the drink sits somewhere around 7% ABV and tastes like peanut butter custard. If you want it closer to a proper holiday eggnog, pour three quarters of an ounce of Skrewball and three quarters of an ounce of bourbon or aged rum instead. The plain spirit cuts through the sweetness and you still get the peanut on the finish. Our Brandy Eggnog recipe is the template: swap the brandy for Skrewball, or split them half and half. The full rundown of which spirits suit the carton lives in what alcohol goes in eggnog.
More mixers we tested
| Mixer | How we pour it | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Cream soda | 2 oz over ice, top with 4 oz | Tastes like a peanut butter blondie |
| Banana liqueur | 1 oz each, shaken, as a shot | The Elvis. Add a bacon garnish if you dare |
| Cold brew and milk | 1.5 oz, 3 oz, 2 oz, over ice | Good at brunch, dangerous before noon |
| Apple cider, hot | 1.5 oz in a mug | Peanut butter on apple slices. Surprisingly good |
| Ginger ale | 2 oz, top with 4 oz | Fine, but the spice and the peanut argue a little |
| Lemonade or tonic | Don’t | Sour and bitter both fight the peanut |
One more: a White Russian with Skrewball standing in for the vodka. Use an ounce and a half of Skrewball, an ounce of Kahlua and an ounce of cream over ice. The recipe as written uses vodka, so call this one a swap. We hand it to anyone who liked the peanut butter cup shot but wanted to sit down with it.
If Skrewball is sharing the shelf with a few other half-used bottles, put them all into CocktailBuilder and it will show you every drink you can already make.
Storing the bottle
Skrewball does not need the fridge. At 35% ABV with no dairy in it, an open bottle is fine in a cupboard for a year or more. The peanut aroma is brightest in the first several months. We do keep ours in the freezer in December, because the shots are nicer poured cold and thick.
Last modified on November 22, 2026