New York Cocktails: The Manhattan, the Bronx, the Brooklyn and the Rest of the City

New York Cocktails: The Manhattan, the Bronx, the Brooklyn and the Rest of the City

New York cocktails and their real histories: the Manhattan, Bronx, Brooklyn and its descendants, New York Sour, Long Island Iced Tea and the Cosmopolitan.

No other city has lent its name to as many drinks as New York, which makes sense once you remember that for most of the late nineteenth century the city’s hotel bars were where American mixology was written down, argued over and exported. Every borough except Staten Island has a cocktail, Brooklyn has spawned an entire family of them, and the suburbs to the east contributed the most notorious highball of the 1970s.

What follows is the set worth knowing, with the history kept to what can actually be documented, since several of these drinks come with origin stories that are better than the truth. Most of them need nothing beyond rye, gin, two vermouths and some citrus, and CocktailBuilder can show which ones a given shelf already covers.

The Manhattan

The Manhattan is whiskey, sweet vermouth and Angostura bitters, stirred and served up, and it is the template from which half of this list descends. Recipes start appearing in bar guides in the mid-1880s, which places its invention somewhere in the decade before.

The story told most often has it mixed at the Manhattan Club for a banquet thrown by Jennie Jerome. It does not hold up. In November 1874, when the banquet supposedly took place, she was in England giving birth to Winston Churchill. The club connection may still be real; the banquet is almost certainly not.

The proportions that work are two parts rye or bourbon to one part vermouth, with two dashes of bitters, because vermouth at a higher ratio flattens the whiskey into something closer to a fortified wine. Rye, with its drier and spicier grain bill, was the original whiskey, and it still produces the sharper drink. The Perfect Manhattan splits the vermouth evenly between sweet and dry, which reads leaner and slightly more herbal. Our Manhattan recipe guide covers the ratios, garnishes and variations in more depth.

Swapping the whiskey for Scotch gives the Rob Roy, which was named in 1894 at the Waldorf-Astoria for an operetta of that name then playing a few blocks away. The same hotel produced the Waldorf, which is essentially a Manhattan with a rinse of absinthe or Pernod, and which shows how freely the hotel’s bartenders riffed on the formula once it caught on.

The Bronx

The Bronx is gin, sweet vermouth, dry vermouth and fresh orange juice, which makes it a perfect martini with fruit in it. It is usually credited to a bartender at the old Waldorf-Astoria around 1900, who is said to have named it after the Bronx Zoo, then newly opened, and by the 1910s it was rivaling the Martini and the Manhattan at American bars.

Then its reputation sank, for a reason that is mostly chemical. Orange juice is less acidic than lemon or lime, so it cannot balance sugar the way a sour’s citrus does, and once the juice is bottled or more than a few hours old, its aromatic oils oxidize and the drink tastes flat. A Bronx made with orange juice squeezed to order, at roughly two ounces of gin to a quarter ounce of each vermouth and an ounce of juice, is a much better drink than its reputation suggests. The Golden Bronx shakes in an egg, which adds body and a foamy cap that carries the orange aroma.

The Brooklyn and its descendants

The Brooklyn was printed in a 1908 bar manual and then largely forgotten, partly because one of its ingredients disappeared from American shelves. The early recipe calls for rye, dry vermouth, a little maraschino liqueur and Amer Picon, a bitter orange aperitif from France that has been difficult to buy in the United States for most of the last century and was later reformulated at a lower proof. The version we link sidesteps the problem by dropping the Picon and using sweet vermouth, which yields something closer to a Manhattan with a cherry-almond edge. Anyone wanting the older profile can add a quarter ounce of a bitter orange amaro in place of the Picon.

During the 2000s, a group of New York bartenders took the Brooklyn as a template and began naming variations after its neighborhoods, a game that produced a small family of rye drinks:

  1. The Red Hook combines rye, maraschino and Punt e Mes, a vermouth sharpened with extra bitterness; there is no entry for it in our database, but it is easy to mix from those three bottles.
  2. The Greenpoint uses rye, sweet vermouth, yellow Chartreuse and bitters, which yields a honeyed, herbal finish.
  3. The Brooklyn Heights brings in dry vermouth, maraschino, an amaro and Campari, so it runs drier and more bitter than its parent.

The Brooklynite, despite the name, belongs to a different family: it is dark Jamaican rum, lime and honey, which makes it a rich cousin of the daiquiri. The borough’s most famous drink contains no alcohol at all, since the Brooklyn egg cream is chocolate syrup, milk and seltzer and has never contained an egg.

Queens, Harlem and the hotel bars

The Queens is gin with both vermouths and a splash of pineapple juice, and it sits alongside a group of borough-named gin drinks from the same era. Pineapple juice carries enough dissolved protein and pectin to whip into a fine, persistent foam when shaken, which is why these drinks arrive with a frothy cap even without egg white. The Harlem takes the same pineapple-and-gin idea and swaps the vermouths for maraschino.

Hotels and clubs left their own marks. The Algonquin is whiskey, dry vermouth and pineapple, named for the hotel whose round table of writers met through the 1920s, while the Stork Club Cocktail mixes gin with orange juice, triple sec, lime and bitters, and was published in the famous nightclub’s own bar book.

The New York Sour

The New York Sour is a whiskey sour with a float of dry red wine. A fruity red that is not too tannic, such as a Malbec or a young Shiraz, poured slowly over the back of a spoon, settles on top because it is less dense than the sugared, citrus-heavy sour below it, and every sip passes through a layer of tannin and dark fruit before reaching the whiskey, so the wine works as a second, drier layer of flavor rather than a garnish.

The New York name is newer than the drink, which seems to have circulated in the 1880s under names such as the Continental Sour, and which may have been popular in Chicago before New York claimed it. The recipe we link uses blended whiskey; bourbon gives a rounder result and rye a spicier one.

The New York Cocktail

The New York Cocktail is whisky, lime juice, sugar and grenadine, finished with an orange twist, and it appears in bar books by the 1930s. It is effectively a whiskey sour tinted pink, which explains why it is rarely ordered today, though it is a useful drink to know when a bottle of real pomegranate grenadine needs using. The linked recipe calls for Canadian whisky, whose lighter body lets the pomegranate come forward.

Long Island Iced Tea and the Cosmopolitan

The Long Island Iced Tea contains vodka, gin, light rum, tequila and triple sec, topped with sour mix and cola, and it contains no tea. It is commonly credited to a bartender at a Long Island bar in the 1970s, although a much older drink from Tennessee shares the name and some of the idea. Its color comes from the splash of cola, and its strength comes from roughly two and a half ounces of spirit in a single glass, which is why it is more potent than it tastes.

The Cosmopolitan is the most recent drink on this list and also the one most clearly tied to Manhattan. Versions with vodka, cranberry and lime circulated in several American cities in the 1980s, but the citrus vodka, Cointreau, fresh lime and cranberry recipe that became the standard took shape in downtown Manhattan restaurants late in that decade. Television did the rest in the late 1990s. Made with fresh lime and only enough cranberry to turn it pale pink, it is sharper and much drier than its reputation.

New Orleans is the only American city with a comparable family tree, and its Sazerac and Vieux Carré grew from the same whiskey-and-vermouth stock; our classic New Orleans cocktails guide traces that branch. New York’s legislature, for its part, chose milk as the official state drink, which leaves the Manhattan with every honor except a legal one.


Last modified on November 16, 2026