
Bourbon Cream Drinks: How to Drink It, and Where It Beats Irish Cream
A regular brought me a bottle of bourbon cream one Christmas. Gift bag, ribbon, the works. He wanted me to make him “something good” with it. I had no idea what to do. Neither did any cocktail book behind my bar.
That’s still mostly the situation. Bourbon cream is a young category. Buffalo Trace makes the one most people have seen, and a few other distilleries have followed with their own. You won’t find a century of recipes for it. Our database doesn’t even list it as an ingredient yet, so on CocktailBuilder you’d search Irish cream and bourbon and work from there.
What I figured out that night, and since: it drinks like Irish cream’s American cousin. Same dairy base. Same low proof. Different spirit underneath. Where Baileys tastes of cocoa and Irish whiskey, bourbon cream leans vanilla, caramel and a little toasted oak. So you drink it the ways you’d drink Baileys, and you borrow Baileys recipes.
On the rocks
Start here. Pour two ounces over one big cube. Done.
People search “Jim Beam bourbon cream on the rocks” a lot. I’ll be straight with you. A lot of them land on our Jim’s Cream, which is Jim Beam and cream soda. That’s a different drink. Bourbon plus cream soda, in a tall glass. Sweet and fizzy. Tastes a bit like bourbon cream with bubbles, actually. Not a bad mistake to make.
Back to the rocks. Don’t use crushed ice. Cream liqueurs go watery fast and the texture is half the point. One large cube melts slow. Grate a little nutmeg on top if you’re feeling fancy. I never did at work. Nobody complained.
Too sweet for you? Add half an ounce of straight bourbon. Stiffens it right up.
Out of the stuff entirely? Make the Bourbon Cream from our site. Bourbon and heavy cream, nothing else, shaken hard with ice. That’s the bottle’s whole idea made fresh, minus the sugar. A teaspoon of maple syrup gets you most of the way back.
In coffee
This is where it earns shelf space.
An ounce and a half in a mug of hot coffee. No sugar needed, the liqueur brings it. Our Bailey’s Cup of Coffee is exactly this with Irish cream. Swap the bottle. The bourbon version tastes more like a caramel latte than a mocha.
For brunch, I’d build the Irish Coffee #2 instead. Coffee, half-and-half, a little sugar, Irish cream. Use bourbon cream and cut the sugar in half. It’s already sweet.
Cold brew works even better. Fill a glass with ice. Three ounces cold brew, two ounces bourbon cream. Stir. That’s my summer order and I’m not taking questions. If you have chocolate ice cream in the freezer, the Iced Irish Coffee turns into a boozy milkshake with the swap.
With root beer
This one surprises people. It shouldn’t. Root beer is vanilla, wintergreen and sassafras-style spice. Bourbon is vanilla and oak. Cream ties the knot.
The template is the Irish Mudslide on our site. Root beer and Baileys, that’s the entire recipe. Use bourbon cream instead. Two ounces liqueur, five or six of cold root beer, tall glass, ice. Pour the root beer slowly. It foams like crazy when it hits the cream.
Want more kick? The Jim Barqs is bourbon and root beer, straight. Add an ounce of bourbon cream to it and you’ve got a grown-up float without the scoop. Or add the scoop. A ball of vanilla ice cream in there is dessert. More in our root beer cocktails roundup.
Eggnog
December, obviously. Bourbon already lives in a lot of eggnog. Bourbon cream doubles down.
Mix it half and half with store eggnog. Grate nutmeg on top. That’s it. Or go homemade with the Bourbon Milk Punch: bourbon, half-and-half, sugar, vanilla, nutmeg. Replace a third of the half-and-half with bourbon cream and skip most of the sugar. It’s lighter than nog and you don’t need eggs.
Irish cream recipes it swaps into
Any drink that uses Baileys as a flavor, not a gimmick, takes bourbon cream fine. Here’s how I’d rate the swaps:
| Drink | What’s in it | How the swap goes |
|---|---|---|
| Mudslide | Vodka, coffee liqueur, Irish cream | Great. Caramel plus coffee. My favorite. |
| Frozen Mudslide | Same, plus vanilla ice cream | Great. Tastes like a fancy shake. |
| White Russian | Vodka, Kahlua, cream or milk | Replace the cream with bourbon cream. Richer. |
| B-52 | Kahlua, Irish cream, Grand Marnier | Works, but layering is touchy. Pour slow. |
| Irish Car Bomb | Stout, Irish cream, Irish whiskey | Skip it. Irish whiskey, Irish cream, Irish stout is the whole point. |
One warning from experience. Cream liqueur curdles in acid. Anything with lemon, lime or a tart mixer turns to cottage cheese in the glass. I learned that one in front of a full bar. Cola too, if it sits. Drink those fast or don’t make them.
Keeping the bottle
It’s a dairy product with alcohol in it. Low proof, so it won’t last forever once opened. Read the label. I keep mine in the fridge and finish it within a few months. The rules are close to Irish cream’s. If it smells sour or looks lumpy, pour it out.
If you want more ideas for the sister bottle, the what to mix with Baileys list works almost one for one. RumChata drinkers have their own mixing guide, and most of those swap in too. Cinnamon and bourbon get along.
That regular, by the way? I ended up making him the root beer one. He came back the next week with a second bottle.
Last modified on November 16, 2026