90s Cocktails: Cosmos, Appletinis and Everything in a Martini Glass

90s Cocktails: Cosmos, Appletinis and Everything in a Martini Glass

Popular 90s cocktails for a themed party: Cosmopolitan, Appletini, Lemon Drop, Chocolate Martini, Long Island, Zima drinks, Mudslide and the UK pub favorites.

If the ’80s poured everything into a highball, the ’90s poured everything into a martini glass. Vodka got a twist of fruit, the suffix “-tini” went on anything pink or green, and a drink was judged at least partly by how it looked under the lights of a lounge with a velvet rope.

We threw a ’90s party last month in a friend’s living room with a CD changer, a borrowed disco ball and a folding table for a bar. People arrived in flannel and slip dresses and asked, more or less in order, for a Cosmo, an Appletini and “whatever that blue thing was.” Here’s what we poured, and how we’d set the bar up again.

The Cosmopolitan

No drink owns the decade like this one. Bartenders in New York and Miami were shaking versions of it in the late ’80s, but it went everywhere in the ’90s, and once Sex and the City put it in Carrie’s hand in 1998, it became shorthand for a whole kind of night out.

Our Cosmopolitan is lemon vodka, Cointreau, cranberry and fresh lime juice, shaken until the tin is too cold to hold. The cranberry is there for color more than flavor, so go light on it: a splash is enough to turn the glass that soft rosy pink. Too much and it drinks like a Cape Codder. For a cheaper party batch, the Cosmopolitan Classic uses plain vodka and triple sec, and honestly most guests won’t taste the difference after the first round.

Appletinis and the sour apple years

The Appletini is the most ’90s-looking drink on this list, a cocktail roughly the color of antifreeze. It came out of the late-decade martini lounge boom, and sour apple schnapps made it possible to mix one anywhere.

Our Appletini is just vodka and sour apple pucker, which is how most bars made it. We like the Sour Apple Martini better for a crowd, since it adds citrus vodka, Cointreau and lemon juice and tastes less like candy. We’ve written up the full Appletini recipe if you want to fuss over the green.

The Washington Apple rode the same sour apple wave: Crown Royal, apple pucker and cranberry. It’s red, sweet and gone in two sips.

Lemon Drops and Kamikazes

The Lemon Drop was the sugar-rimmed cousin of the Cosmo, and a lot of people’s first martini-glass drink. Vodka, triple sec, superfine sugar and fresh lemon juice. We roll the rim of each glass in sugar ahead of time and stack them in the freezer, which makes the night go much faster once the doorbell starts ringing.

The Kamikaze is the Lemon Drop’s rougher sibling: vodka, triple sec and lime. Poured as a shot it was everywhere on a ’90s bar crawl.

Chocolate martinis and dessert in a glass

Then there were the “martinis” that had nothing to do with gin. The Chocolate Martini is vodka and crème de cacao, and the fun is all in the glass: we swirl chocolate syrup inside before we pour, so it slides down in stripes. The Mudslide, coffee liqueur, Baileys and vodka, belongs on the same dessert tray. Blend it with ice and milk as the Mudslide Blended and you have the drink that chain restaurants built whole laminated menus around.

Long Islands and the blue drinks

Every ’90s bar crawl ended with somebody ordering a Long Island Iced Tea. Vodka, gin, light rum, tequila and triple sec, sour mix, a splash of cola for the tea color. It doesn’t taste strong, which is the whole problem with it. We pour a half-size version at home and nobody complains.

That “blue thing” our guest asked about turned out to be the Adios Motherfucker, a Long Island with blue curaçao in place of the cola and 7-Up on top. Swap the curaçao for Midori and you have the Tokyo Tea, which glows green.

Zima, the clear malt beverage

Zima went national in the mid-’90s, a clear, lightly lemony malt drink that was supposed to be the alternative to beer. People immediately started mixing things into it. The most famous trick was dropping a Jolly Rancher into the bottle and waiting for it to dye the whole thing, but the drinks that stuck around in our database are simpler. The Zima Blaster is Zima with Chambord, which turns it pink, and the Zimadori Zinger adds Midori. Zima has come and gone and come back more than once; we’ve rounded up what to do with a bottle in our post on Zima comeback cocktails.

The shots tray

No ’90s party works without a tray of shooters going around the room. These are the three we got asked for most:

  1. The Red Headed Slut, Jägermeister with peach schnapps and cranberry, which is a lot sweeter than anyone expects from Jäger.
  2. A Purple Hooter, vodka and Chambord with a splash of 7-Up.
  3. The Buttery Nipple, butterscotch liqueur with Irish cream, which we float on top with the back of a spoon.

The Woo Woo, the Melon Ball and Sex on the Beach all carried over from the decade before and were still ordered constantly. We covered them properly in our 80s cocktails roundup, so pour from that list too if your crowd is a little older.

90s cocktails in the UK

Across the Atlantic, the decade tasted a little different. British pubs and clubs ran on alcopops and bright vodka drinks, with the Blue Lagoon, vodka, blue curaçao and lemonade, turning up in a lot of holiday photos. The Snakebite and Black, lager and cider with a dash of blackcurrant, was the student-union classic, and some pubs refused to serve it. Woo Woos and the Slippery Nipple were standard calls at the bar. For a UK-themed night, those four and a few Cosmos cover it.

How we set up the bar

We kept it to five bottles: plain vodka, citrus vodka, triple sec, sour apple schnapps and crème de cacao, plus Chambord for the shots. Fresh limes and lemons, cranberry juice, a jug of homemade sour mix, a can of chocolate syrup and a plate of sugar for rims. Before shopping we ran that list through CocktailBuilder to be sure nothing was missing, and it covered the Cosmo, the Appletini, the Lemon Drop, the Kamikaze, the Chocolate Martini and the Purple Hooter with nothing left over.

Martini glasses matter here more than for any other decade. Thrift stores have stacks of them. We bought twelve for less than a pizza, and by midnight most of them had a lime wheel or a gummy worm on the rim.

Going further back, the 70s cocktails list has the Harvey Wallbanger and the Tequila Sunrise, which make a good follow-up theme for the next one.


Last modified on November 16, 2026