21st Birthday Drinks: What to Order, Make and Toast With

21st Birthday Drinks: What to Order, Make and Toast With

21st birthday drinks that actually taste good: what to order at the bar on the night, an easy party menu to make at home, and a few birthday shots worth the toast.

Somebody always buys the birthday kid a terrible first drink. We have watched it happen at more twenty-firsts than we can count: a round of the cheapest tequila, a grimace, a photo of the grimace. It’s tradition, apparently. We’d like to propose a better one, where the first legal drink is something you’d actually order again.

Most people at twenty-one haven’t had much chance to figure out what they like. So this list leans toward drinks that taste good on the first try, are easy to name at a crowded bar, and won’t flatten you before the cake comes out.

First drinks that taste good

People search for “21st birthday drinks for girls” and “for guys,” but underneath, both are really asking whether you want sweet or not. We’d rather sort it that way.

If you like…Order thisWhat’s in it
Sweet and citrusyLemon DropVodka, triple sec, fresh lemon, sugar rim
Fruity, nothing fussySex on the BeachVodka, peach schnapps, cranberry, orange
Something to photographPornstar MartiniVanilla vodka, passion fruit liqueur and juice, lime, Prosecco
Sweet with a tart edgeAmaretto SourAmaretto, sour mix
A first try at whiskeyWhiskey SourWhiskey, sour mix
Salt and limeMargaritaBlanco tequila, Cointreau, fresh lime
CoffeeEspresso MartiniVodka, Kahlua, crème de cacao, espresso

The Lemon Drop tastes like lemonade that has made up its mind. The Pornstar Martini arrives with a little glass of Prosecco on the side, meant to be sipped between mouthfuls, and it’s the showiest thing on most menus. If someone at the table claims not to like whiskey, the Whiskey Sour is the drink that changes their mind more often than not. And the Espresso Martini has one practical advantage on a birthday: it keeps you upright until midnight.

What to order at the bar on the night

Bars on birthday nights are loud and busy, and the bartender has about five seconds for you. Name the drink, have your ID out before you reach the front, and keep it simple. Our guide to drinks to order at a bar for beginners goes deeper, but a few rules help on the night itself.

Order things with three or four ingredients. A Washington Apple, which is Crown Royal, sour apple schnapps and cranberry, is quick for the bar and tastes like a green apple candy. An Aperol Spritz is low in alcohol and lasts a while in the glass, which is useful when friends keep handing you new ones.

Be wary of the Long Island Iced Tea. Four spirits plus triple sec, topped with sour mix and cola, and it tastes far gentler than it is. It’s a classic birthday order and also the drink most likely to end your night by ten.

If the group wants a round of shots, steer it toward something that tastes good. A Kamikaze of vodka, triple sec and lime is clean and citrusy. A Vegas Bomb drops Crown Royal and butterscotch liqueur into Red Bull, and a Jäger Bomb does the same with Jägermeister. Our roundup of shots that taste good has plenty more that won’t make anyone wince for the camera.

Birthday shots worth the toast

There is a small family of shots that taste, more or less, like cake. The best known is the birthday cake shot: citron vodka and hazelnut liqueur, followed by a bite of sugared lemon. The order of the two creates the effect, and it genuinely works. Our database has the same build as the Chocolate Cake Shooter, even though there’s no chocolate in it.

A couple of other cake-flavored options are easy to set up at home:

  1. The Wedding Cake Shot uses vanilla vodka and Frangelico with the same sugared-lemon trick.
  2. The Pineapple Upside Down Cake Shot #2 blends amaretto, butterscotch schnapps and pineapple juice, and tastes remarkably close to its name.
  3. The Cupcake is just vanilla vodka and Sprite, which makes it a mellow drink to sip while the candles get lit.

A 21st birthday menu to make at home

A house party gives you more control, and honestly the drinks tend to be better. We’d keep the menu short: one big-batch drink, one sparkling option, one shot, and something good without alcohol.

For the batch, a pitcher of margaritas is hard to beat. Mix tequila, orange liqueur and fresh lime two to one to one, chill it, and let people pour over ice with or without a salted rim. For the sparkling option, set out a bottle of bubbly with orange juice for Mimosas, or a bowl of berries and let guests drop a few into a glass of plain Prosecco. The cake shots above cover the toast. And a pitcher of something like a Virgin Sex on the Beach, with orange, cranberry, peach nectar and grenadine, means the friends who aren’t drinking still get a glass that looks like everyone else’s.

Before you shop, it helps to check what the cupboard already covers. Enter the bottles you have into CocktailBuilder and you’ll often find the party is half-stocked.

Water, food and the long night

Eat a real dinner first, not just a slice of pizza at midnight. Drink a glass of water between rounds, and keep in mind that friends buying you drinks will outpace you if you try to match every one. Nobody minds if you nurse a spritz for an hour.

The best twenty-first we ever hosted ended with the birthday girl asking for the margarita recipe on her way out. She’d had three, slowly, and still remembered she wanted it. We wrote it on the back of a napkin, two to one to one.


Last modified on November 16, 2026